Reclaiming Education Bill Takes another Step Forward (includes sound files)

Posted by

Warwick Mansell made the opening speech for the debate
Warwick Mansell made the opening speech for the debate

The seven organisations which comprise the Reclaiming Education Alliance were out in full support of the ‘Reclaiming Education Bill 2015’ at a meeting in the House of Commons on Wednesday 25th February.

John Edmonds, in the Chair contextualised much of the prior work and activity that had preceded the evolution of the draft bill. As he pointed out, we were now at a critical time for education and the preservation of what remains of a national public service must be our top priority.

The keynote speaker was Guardian columnist Warwick Mansell who delivered a very thoughtful and incisive analysis of the state of education as perceived by the wider public. He outlined in crisp detail what had happened to the former democratically accountable relationship between the education service and the Secretary of State and how, in the face of opposition by 98% of parents in one school, academisation was forced through at the stroke of a pen by the unelected Lord Nash. He also highlighted the secrecy which surrounds the decision making in the DfE. In terms of three key principles, equality, inclusion and democracy the current administration had comprehensively failed.

Former NUT senior solicitor, Graham Clayton, who had drafted the bill in front of the meeting took us through how the now well established ‘seven principles’ could be enacted in law. The bill, though written in parliamentary language, showed clearly how in practice the principles could be converted into policy and underwritten by law. The bill was accompanied by some very lucid explanatory notes.

In the discussion that followed several other important issues were raised. Among these topics were Early Years education, changes to the exams system and the necessity or otherwise of the National Curriculum. Questions were raised to about the omission explicitly of grammar schools and whether we should refer specifically to faith schools. John Edmonds was clear about how the process had required clear prioritisation and acknowledgement of the fact that all seven organisations were not going to agree on every issue. Hence the focus on the seven most important areas of common agreement. The meeting ended with a clear determination by those present to campaign for the ‘Reclaiming Education Bill 2015’ in the remaining weeks before the general election.

Hear the main speeches and some of the contributions

1. Opening remarks by John Edmonds


2. Opening speech by Warwick Mansell


3. Introduction to the Draft Bill by Graham Clayton


From the discussion

1. Q&A on faith schools (with response by John Bolt – SEA General Secretary)


2. Eddie Playfair (SEA Vice-Chair) on the draft Bill and democracy


3. Sheila Doré on (SEA Chair) Labour, local authorities and schools

One comment

  1. There are a lot of goods idea and proposals in what was presented to this meeting. But how does any of this connect with Labour Party policy? It is clear, is it not, that some of the proposals are in flat contradiction to Labour policy? Thus, Labour supports the academies programme and even free schools (which, despite some rhetorical bluster, reappear renamed as ‘parent led academies’). Moreover, despite the fact of all the effort that went into this meeting, and its location in the House of Commons, only two Labour MPs were in attendance. So let’s be realistic: Labour isn’t listening. The ideas are good but the direction of travel that they propose are radically different from those adopted by the Labour Party.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s